Message from the Chair of the Criminal Justice Section

Message from the Chair of the Criminal Justice Section


Below is Tucker Stanclift’s first “Message from the Chair” of the NYSBA Criminal Justice Section.

“Welcome to my first Chair’s Message in the Criminal Justice Section’s New York
Criminal Law Bulletin. Most of you have been loyal members of our section. Many of you are
also active in the “business” of our section. Thank you.

I am excited to begin my tenure as CJS Chair with a strategic planning session that will
take place early this Fall in Nassau County. It is my hope that the leadership of this section can
focus on redefining the ways in which we deliver CLE and other member benefits. We live in an
ever changing technological world and you have many other choices in providers of CLE. Our
goal will be to examine how the Criminal Justice Section can be your “go to” source for all your
criminal law practice needs. To that end, I invite all of you to email me ( )
any of your ideas, comments, or concerns.

Why the Criminal Justice Section?

No other section of the New York State Bar Association, nor any other organization in
my view, embodies such diverse perspectives on a single area of law. We are a unique blend of
practitioners from varied walks of life, professional backgrounds, levels of experience, and
ethnic diversity. We are judges. We are public defenders. We are private defense counsel. We
are prosecutors. I believe this diversity allows us an inimitable environment to challenge each
other and debate the critical issues facing criminal justice in New York. I also believe that a
significant part of this organization’s duty is to improve your professional experience as a
criminal lawyer. This section should provide you with skills training, resources, and professional
development opportunities. I certainly have benefited greatly from the awesome influence of the
venerable members of this section since I was a young lawyer. I am honored to be your Chair
and to serve you together with the other officers: Sherry Levin Wallach (Former Chair), Robert
Masters (Chair-Elect), David Cohen (Secretary) and Leah Nowotarski (Treasurer). Together with
our distinguished Executive Committee, we endeavor to confront injustice, promote diversity,
influence legislation, and learn from each other.

Our foremost objective is to carry on the section’s traditions of excellence. Our
publications and CLE programs have always been among the best that the New York State Bar
Association has to offer. The manner in which we continue these traditions may change in the
coming year or so depending on the outcome of the strategic planning retreat this Fall. Every
organization has traditions, but it also needs new goals and new initiatives from time to time. As
a former Chair of the Young Lawyers Section, I appreciate fresh new ideas which take into
account the time and budgetary constraints of today’s criminal lawyer. Again, please forward
any ideas!

How can you be involved?

Get a seat at the table. Decisions are made by those that show up. Contact me with your
area of interest and we can find a spot on a committee. Come to our meetings. Attend and
participate in our programs. The Fall program will be on October 6, 2017, at the Nassau County
Bar Association. More information about that meeting and program will be coming to you soon.
As an active member, you can also help shape the future of our profession by helping us advance
our initiatives.

We seek to continue some of the initiatives advocated over the last two years by former
Chair, Sherry Levin Wallach. These initiatives include legislation for the sealing of convictions,
addressing wrongful convictions, funding for indigent legal services, raising the age of criminal
responsibility, counsel at first appearance, and bail reform. Our efforts in these areas have
demonstrated that your involvement can lead to real change. Despite these successes, however,
we still have a great deal of work to do to ensure the implementation of these reforms will be
applied fairly and effectively. I will be calling upon all active members to play a role in
advancing the objectives of this section, as well as, the initiatives of the New York State Bar
Association that will be identified by our President, Sharon Stern Gerstman.

Our biggest project in the coming years will be Discovery Reform. An overhaul of New
York’s criminal discovery rules will help innocent or over-charged defendants fairly prepare for
trial and it will encourage guilty defendants to plead guilty without needless and costly delays. I
expect nothing less than a healthy professional debate among our diverse leadership on how best
to accomplish this reform.

As I look forward with anticipation to the exciting work to be done this year and next, I
feel trepidation because it seems like times are changing for many criminal lawyers. I understand
that with change comes challenge. If you want change, I challenge you to be an active member.
Our membership is down year after year. The reasons for the decrease in membership, in my
view, is a fundamental disconnect between the Section’s “business” and our existing members’
and potential members’ professional needs. I hope to explore solutions to these challenges in the
coming year. Thank you for the privilege of serving as your Chair.”

– Tucker C. Stanclift

Schedule a Case Review

This is for adminstrative purposes only. All information will be kept in the strictest confidence.